Community Portraits
Duncan Timms (University of Stirling)
Community Portraits is an online programme, designed
• to enable participants to explore their own communities
and to share their views with others;
•
to enable participants to find out about other communities and
make comparisons;
•
to provide an opportunity for participants to work with others
from different backgrounds;
•
to produce Web-pages presenting their communities..
The module is designed on the principle that community arises
from communication and uses online collaboration as a means to
explore the formation and maintenance of a sense of community
identity.
The module is run by the University of Stirling and lasts a
nominal 12 weeks.
The first run of the programme involved professional
workers in the health and social care fields working and living
in the
Highlands of Scotland, Lapland, central Sweden and around Stuttgart
in Germany. A brief outline of the module is given in the appendix
and an evaluation is contained in a report prepared for the EC
by the course tutor, Liz Timms (1999b: http://www.schema.stir.ac.uk/Deliverables/D4.1.pdf).
Participants in the module commented that the course appeared
to fulfil its objectives, leading to a broadening of perspectives, “even
some new ideas and information”. Participants also commented
on the acquisition of new communi-cation skills and appreciated
the way in which collaboration on-line led to the development
of a learning community. Negative comments were mostly directed
at problems with the technology, but also noted the need to establish
roles and responsibilities within workgroups as quickly as possible.
There is a potential conflict between the provision of too much
information and a prescriptive work schedule and encouraging
groups to develop their own approach. It was also observed that
the experience of shared technical problems – notably involving
a synchronous chat button which was very temperamental – actually
helped the participants to bond. The experience of tackling a
common irritation helped the development of trust.
The second iteration was with groups of lone parents and retired
people in a stigmatized suburb of Stockholm (see Appendix C).
It had been intended to pair the Stockholm group with a number
of people living in a disadvantaged area in Glasgow, but the
Scottish group were unable to maintain their online presence
and the Swedish group were left to develop their Portraits by
themselves. As when the participants were professional care workers,
the experience seems to have been successful in terms of community-building,
leading to collaboration among individuals who had no previous
knowledge of each other. Through sharing experiences and collaborating
online the participants were able to develop an improved image
of their community and to promote this publicly. At the same
time the progress of the group was hindered by inter-personal
difficulties which would probably not have been so influential
if interaction had been wholly online.
The most recent outings of Community Portraits have involved
students concerned with the approaches of three Scottish universities
to disability issues. A brief description of the module is appended
(see also http://www.psychology.stir.ac.uk/staff/alaing/index.php).
The course tutor, Adele Laing is carrying out an ethnographic
study of disabling practices in Scottish Higher Education. She
points out that her research has suggested a consider-able gap
between the policies and procedures theat universities present
concerning disability and the reality of student experience.
Community Portraits provides a mechanism for enabling the student
perspective to be heard and for the students concerned to develop
an ongoing community which will help to promote changes in institutional
policies.
|